Rating of, & Comment on, USA Judges

 Your GENUINE COMMENTS will add towards CURBING JUDICIAL IMMUNITY of judges, WORLDWIDE. That this is possible, is a major positive impact of the Internet. We do not need a change of the law to make Judges accountable. You comments, together with comments of other "plain citizens" throughout the world, who would be the people to comprise an Independant GRAND JURY, will cause this to occur.     See how this will occur on our Parent website

Proceed to the NEW IMPROVED forum for Rating Judges of
US of A [United States of America] plus much more]
. See our NEW EXTENDED POLICY:
The OLD forum is still onsite immediately below  [but you can no longer write to it].  You may have noticed that it had been bastardized.  That parasite's IP is in Hungary, so he will probably not read this but go straight to the OLD forum input at teh bottom of this page.   His frustration as he tries to write to it may cause him to break his computer or keyboard.  We can but hope. I soon removed the garbage from this page.   All REAL COMMENTS will remain there always.  If you contributed to the original forum, you may wish to START A THREAD in the NEW FORUM and copy your original contribution  into that new thread.

If you have any problems with this site, please contact me.

from the SITE administrator:
Russell Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA: 

NEW EXTENDED POLICY;  Future comment is not limited to just JUDGES. ANY LEGAL ISSUE in the USA is valid content.  This could be any LEGAL ISSUE.  It could be a problem with a neighbour, over a fence, or a problem with a LAWYER, or CITY OFFICIAL.  If you have any legal issue, just start a new THREAD.  I believe the INTERNET is the way to resolve legal issues, rather than the courts, and I am trained as a LAWYER with an LLB, and am doing my PhD in law at the moment.  The INTERNET  is very powerful; for little people to fight back against the 'powerful'.  It will empower you.  
 
You are welcome to vent any legal issue here.  You may even wish to build your own FREE simple website, and link to it from this FORUM. There really is no catch.  It is totally free.  [Hard to believe on the internet.] It is limited to 50MB but it will take a lot of writing by you to fill that.  There are no pop-up ads. It is all you need while you are learning. 
 
We already have very high Google rankings and that should improve even more.   That should ensure you have very good google rankings for your new site, very quickly, within four days. [It took me two months for Google to index my first site from August 2006.]   If you have any problems, contact me.

A point to note is that the SERVER for this site is NOT IN THE USA.  

 
Miss Heavey,     Dated:  05.05.08   Time:  09:26 Web: www.stopinjusticenow.com
Country:  England  City: Birmingham  State: Birmingham
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Judge McFarlane  Court: Family Judge
Ordered 10 police to remove 3 children from thier mothers arms, the kids were screaming to be left with her, they were holding her but the police ripped them off, just to be put in care, no chargers of abuse or neglect on the mother, just the judge did not like the mothers attitude of challenging the LA social worke

Russell G H Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA; Legal Researcher.,     Dated:  11.05.08   Time:  14:42 Web: haigreport.com/solutiontoorganisedcorruptioninlawcourtsgovernment.html
Country:    City:   State: 
Rating:   Judge:   Court: 
CECILIA M. ALTONAGA
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA, MIAMI DIVISION, CASE NO. 08-20533-CIV-ALTONAGA/Brown, entitled FLORIDA J.A.I.L. 4 JUDGES, Plaintiff, vs. THE FLORIDA BAR et al, Defendants.

FLORIDA J.A.I.L. 4 JUDGES, et al Plaintiff,
vs.
THE FLORIDA BAR, et al., Defendants.

THE FLORIDA BAR Association.

http://haigreport.com/solutiontoorganisedcorruptioninlawcourtsgovernment.html
http://www.jail4judges.org/PressReleases/PR_2007-02-21.htm
http://www.floridajail4judges.org/

This case, UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA, MIAMI DIVISION, CASE NO. 08-20533-CIV-ALTONAGA/Brown, entitled FLORIDA J.A.I.L. 4 JUDGES, Plaintiff, vs. THE FLORIDA BAR et al, Defendants, epitomises the corruption in the legal profession and the judiciary whose members are promoted from the more corrupt members of the legal profession. The Florida chapter of JAIL4Judges brought this action against the FLORIDA BAR Association. The Florida Bar Asssociation has been acting as a corrupt political organisation to defeat the Jail initiative, in much the same way as the Bar Association of South Dakota has used a litany of corrupt methods to defeat the JAIL Initiative in South Dakota. The Florida Bar Asssociation is corruptly acting for the benefit of the Florida judiciary. This clearly displays that the lawyers interests are more closely aligned to the interests of the judiciary than to the interests of their clients. Whether they win or or lose for their client they are still entitled to payment, and the corrupt judiciary will issue orders that the corrupt lawyers are to be apaid.

Two basic proposition of the Legal System:
1) Client Privilege, so lawyers can conspire with their criminal clients in secret and never be forced to devulge the substance of their discussion and
2}the proposition that the case pleaded need have no resemblance to the truth or reality so to permit criminal defendants and criminal plaintiffs to decide as late as possible in the \"legal process\", on which scenario they will stand the best chance of being able to cheat the other party to the action.

The JAIL4judges initiative is directed at making judges accountable for their decisions

This decision by CECILIA M. ALTONAGA is beyond logical dissection and cannot be subjected to rational logic. The decision is proof positive that the Justice system cannot be used to make the justice system more accountable to the people and the constitution It is a logical dilemma. Clearly, as shown in the South Dakota experience, the judiciary and legal profession can be seen as the one corrupt entity, in opposition to the Community and constitution. Asking a court to decide this matter, is to ask Ceasar to judge Ceasar. Any reasonably informed member of the community has to perceive, at the least, a significant degree of bias in a judge deciding a matter relevant to Judicial Accountability. We know the judiciary is corrupt worldwide. That is the reason for the need of the JAIL initiative. The legal profession and police forces worldwide are also corrupt. Consider: usually, police marry police and lawyers marry lawyers. No-one else would have them and they need to shore each other up to continue their \"career\" which is equivalent to their continuing their corruption.

The JAIL initiative is directed at solely the judiciary. The legal profession, as proxy for the judiciary, is opposing JAIL by every conceivable method including all corrupt methods possible.

Legislating JAIL4judges will be the final step in reforming the judiciary by securing its accountability. By one degree of separation, this should secure the accountability of the legal profession, and police worldwide. This will not just happ

CECILIA M. ALTONAGA,     Dated:  for Miami   Time:  Florida Web: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA, MIAMI DIVISION, CASE NO. 08-20533-CIV-ALTONAGA/Brown
Country:    City:   State: 
Rating:   Judge:   Court: 
Evil

Russell G H Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA, Legal Researcher.,,     Dated:  11.05.08   Time:  15:12 Web: haigreport.com/solutiontoorganisedcorruptioninlawcourtsgovernment.html
Country:  for USA  City: for Miami  State: Florida
Rating: Evil"  Judge: CECILIA M. ALTONAGA  Court: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA, MIAMI DIVISION, CASE NO. 08-20533-CIV-ALTONAGA/Brown
[Continued from the two postings immediately above.]

Legislating JAIL4judges will be the final step in reforming the judiciary by securing its accountability. By one degree of separation, this should secure the accountability of the legal profession, and police worldwide. This will not just happen. The judiciary will resist in all ways possible, as shown in this case. The heavy lifting will need to be done by the Internet [the subset of the Internet I call the WEBNET: AND by such sites as the http://www.jail4judges.org/PressReleases/PR_2007-02-21.htm
http://www.floridajail4judges.org/
http://jail4judges.org
http://floridajail4judges.org
and all of my sites accessible from the index page to this site. These include
http://haigreport.com/solutiontoorganisedcorruptioninlawcourtsgovernment.html
http://haigreport.com
http://shonksandshysters.com
http://austlawpublish.com/ plus
http://RateUSJudges.com
http://RateUKJudges.com
http://RateNZJudges.com
http://RateAustralianJudges.com
http://RateCanadianJudges.com
http://RateIndianJudges.com as well as the Universal
http://RateAllJudges.com /.

-Kind regards,
**********************************************
Russell G H Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA
Legal Researcher,
ex-Member of the Standing Committee of Convocation of
The UNIVERSITY of QUEENSLAND
**********************************************

Keith Allison,     Dated:  14.05.08   Time:  07:02 Web:
Country:  USA  City: Yakima  State: Washington
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Francis James Gavin  Court: Yakima County Superior Court
I rate judge Gavin as an evil judge due to his allowing himself to be approached off the bench by a special interest group of dentists who ordered him to change his verdict of not guilty of practicing dentistry without a license of a denturist in Yakima county. Shortly after he complied with dentistry\'s demand, he was nominated for a position on the federal bench, but fortunately, he was not seated on the federal bench

Richard Anthony Lopez,     Dated:  14.05.08   Time:  07:38 Web:
Country:  Nevada state  City: Pahrump town  State: Nevada state
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Parley R. Baldwin  Court: Second District Court, Weber County Utah
Judge Baldwin dismissed my actions/motions/petitions requesting the court to enforce the laws of the state of Utah regarding the non-compliance with court orders by the mother of my children who has kidnapped and held for ransom my two beautiful children. The mother refuses to comply with the divorce decree and corresponding contempt orders from Colorado; orders which were properly domesticated in Utah. The alleged Judge dismissed my actions and attacked me by purporting to order me, couching such order in a Memorandum Decision, to submit to physical and psychological inspection. Judge Baldwin is a felonious criminal doing business in a chancery court which is a mockery of justice

Linda Weston,     Dated:  14.05.08   Time:  08:42 Web:
Country:  USA  City: Salem  State: IL
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Kathleen Moran  Court: Marion County
This judge let a rapist walk free when he openly admitted in court that he rapped my daughter. The judge ingored him and so did Child protection Services. He was not ordered to jail or even put on a sex offender list. He is still walking free

Laser Haas,     Dated:  14.05.08   Time:  09:25 Web: fraud-corruption-mnat.townhall.com/default.aspx
Country:  USA  City: Los Angeles  State: CA
Rating: irrelevant"  Judge: Chief Justice Mary F Walrath  Court: Delaware Bankruptcy Court
We provided irrefutable proof (court docket records and affidavits) of perjury and fraud on the Court. The US Dept of Justice then made a motion to Disgorge the Law firm of TBF for $1.6 million.
the Wall Street Journal reported on the story www.wjfa.net/bk/etoys.html to see the actual article.

The Disgorge motion stated that the attorneys were vastly experienced, that they were forewarned not to do the acts they did, that the acts were deliberate, rather than inadvertent.

The Dept of Justice Asst US Trustee also testified that the parties considered amending their Rule 2014 Affidavits and decided against doing so, when the non disclosure of conflict of interest issues became readily apparent in another case.

The Dept of Justice concluded that the harm was materiall adverse, that they destroyed the Congressional intent of a diametrically opposed Creditor v Debtor (as both MNAT and TBF confessed to not informing the Court that TBF planted a paid associate of TBF within the Debtor (Barry Gold) who then became CEO and President of eToys.

The document concluded that Fraud on the Court occurred, even though it only addressed 3 out of the 100 felny violations documented.

Then, less than 10 days later, the Dept of Justice Attorney, Mark Kenney, issued a Stipulation to Settle that gave implied blanket immunity to the perpetrators of Fraud upon the Court.

Then, armed with such immunity and no reaction by Chief Justice Mary F Walrath, the parties engaged in another $100 million in fraud in another case.

When we discovered that and pointed it out, the Dept of Justice intervened and had our proofs of perjury and fraud stricken from the record by the judge.

Then MFW speciously handed our $3 million dollar claim of completed, court approved work over to another justice, who let our trial be rescheduled, then let our attorney withdraw, then allowed the parties who had confessed to filing more than 34 false affidavits, where they then testified, supplying a forged document, stating that we just Waived our rights to the $3 million dollars and expenses.

Then the Judge dismissed us as he refused to permit our new attorney to speak.

Then we appealled,

Then Chief Justice Mary F Walrath headed off the appeal, be submitting an Opinion on Oct 4, 2005 and corresponding Order that approved the Illegal Stipulation to Settle.

We rate her as irrelevant, because we cannot prove what compensation she has received,

She is either incompetent or corrupt, that needs to be determined,

However,
Her rulings, being arbitrary and capricious, as self documented as Contrary to the Facts and the LAW is irrefutable. For despite the confessions to filing more than 34 false affidavits and the TBF law firm confessing that it paid Barry Gold four separate payments of $30,000 each prior to placing him within the Debtor illegally, Judge Walrath simply ruled that no perjury had been documented and refused to refer the matter to the US Attorney.

They believe in their own babbling bull s--- soooo much, they feel they can do anything, as they have immunity.

Stand up and fight for your American Way of Life
OR
LET IT GO!


Carol Ann Jacques,     Dated:  14.05.08   Time:  12:45 Web:
Country:  USA  City: Warwick  State: R I
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Arthur N. Votolato  Court: Rhode Island
The Honorable Arthur N. Votolato knowingly,intentionally,and deliberately violated constitutionallaw
while acting in the sytem pertaining to Pro Se Adversary AP-01107. Judge Votolato and attorney\'s created
their own law.The court record was tampered with. The law was brought to the attention of Judge
Votolato.The Judge failed to justify his action. Therefore,ignorance of the law cannot be claimed.
The Honorable Arthur N. Votolato allowed felony grand theft in his courtroom. He should be removed
from the bench and indicted. Why should people be lenient with judges,who brake the law.

Roberta,     Dated:  14.05.08   Time:  12:58 Web:
Country:  USA  City: Rochester Hills  State: Mi
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Daniel Patrick O\'Brien  Court: Family Court
Judge Daniel Patrick O\'Brien is corrupt. He is one of many judges who take campaign contributions in excess of the 7th Judicial Cannon. O\'Brien had a record number of complaints against him and was removed from family court and is now in criminal court. He allows women and children to be abused and rewards the abuser

Louise,     Dated:  14.05.08   Time:  13:02 Web:
Country:  USA  City: Troy  State: Mi
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Chabot  Court: Family Court
Judge Chabot is an alcoholic who does nothing to protect people from their abuser. David Gorcyca- the Oakland County Prosecutor exposed Chabot for her drunkeness

RM Hymes,     Dated:  14.05.08   Time:  13:52 Web:
Country:  USA  City: Alaska  State: 99709
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Ralph R. Beistline  Court: 4th Judicial District
Beistline was the sitting judge on a criminal case (which, at the most should have been a misdemeanor), and now is the judge on a foreclosure case against us. He was also instrumental for hauling my husband back into court for alleged parole violations on the criminal case. Not only did my husband not violate the parole, but those particular violations had nothing to do with the original case. Beistline has refused to recuse himself on more than one occasion, when he should have recused himself on judicial principles (Guess that\'s a contradiction of terms).

Laser Haas,     Dated:  15.05.08   Time:  05:11 Web: fraud-corruption-mnat.townhall.com/default.aspx
Country:  USA  City: Los Angeles  State: CA
Rating: irrelevant"  Judge: Chief Justice Mary F Walrath  Court: Delaware Bankruptcy Court
We provided irrefutable proof (court docket records and affidavits) of perjury and fraud on the Court. The US Dept of Justice then made a motion to Disgorge the Law firm of TBF for $1.6 million.
the Wall Street Journal reported on the story www.wjfa.net/bk/etoys.html to see the actual article.

The Disgorge motion stated that the attorneys were vastly experienced, that they were forewarned not to do the acts they did, that the acts were deliberate, rather than inadvertent.

The Dept of Justice Asst US Trustee also testified that the parties considered amending their Rule 2014 Affidavits and decided against doing so, when the non disclosure of conflict of interest issues became readily apparent in another case.

The Dept of Justice concluded that the harm was materiall adverse, that they destroyed the Congressional intent of a diametrically opposed Creditor v Debtor (as both MNAT and TBF confessed to not informing the Court that TBF planted a paid associate of TBF within the Debtor (Barry Gold) who then became CEO and President of eToys.

The document concluded that Fraud on the Court occurred, even though it only addressed 3 out of the 100 felny violations documented.

Then, less than 10 days later, the Dept of Justice Attorney, Mark Kenney, issued a Stipulation to Settle that gave implied blanket immunity to the perpetrators of Fraud upon the Court.

Then, armed with such immunity and no reaction by Chief Justice Mary F Walrath, the parties engaged in another $100 million in fraud in another case.

When we discovered that and pointed it out, the Dept of Justice intervened and had our proofs of perjury and fraud stricken from the record by the judge.

Then MFW speciously handed our $3 million dollar claim of completed, court approved work over to another justice, who let our trial be rescheduled, then let our attorney withdraw, then allowed the parties who had confessed to filing more than 34 false affidavits, where they then testified, supplying a forged document, stating that we just Waived our rights to the $3 million dollars and expenses.

Then the Judge dismissed us as he refused to permit our new attorney to speak.

Then we appealled,

Then Chief Justice Mary F Walrath headed off the appeal, be submitting an Opinion on Oct 4, 2005 and corresponding Order that approved the Illegal Stipulation to Settle.

We rate her as irrelevant, because we cannot prove what compensation she has received,

She is either incompetent or corrupt, that needs to be determined,

However,
Her rulings, being arbitrary and capricious, as self documented as Contrary to the Facts and the LAW is irrefutable. For despite the confessions to filing more than 34 false affidavits and the TBF law firm confessing that it paid Barry Gold four separate payments of $30,000 each prior to placing him within the Debtor illegally, Judge Walrath simply ruled that no perjury had been documented and refused to refer the matter to the US Attorney.

They believe in their own babbling bull s--- soooo much, they feel they can do anything, as they have immunity.

Stand up and fight for your American Way of Life
OR
LET IT GO!


Michael Jack Stephens,     Dated:  16.05.08   Time:  00:47 Web:
Country:  U.S.A  City: Bloomingdale  State: Georgia
Rating: Evil"  Judge: David C. Bonfiglio  Court: Elkhart Superior Court 6; Elkhart Indiana
This judge has violated his Oath of Office, The Indiana Child Support Guidelines, The Indiana Parenting Time guidelines, and destoryed a young mans life, and his alleged son\'s life as well. Judges in American have judicial immunity. We sued this judge and several others only to be confronted with Judicial immunity, in Federal court, South Bend Indiana division. This judge changed unlawfully the amount of child support in direct violation of the Indiana Child support guidelines. This judges does not have a bond on file, and his Oath of Office has not been updated since the last election. This judge and other are violating the RICO act by conspiring to steal children and by kidnapping them for the Incentive payment program under 42 U.S.C. 658a, the states gets 2X (two times) the amount of child support so collected. This is wrong.
This judge and other Indiana Court of appeals judges have also denied this party an appeal, by dismissing every appeal this person has filed: Since 2004 (march) this person has had every motion, appeal, and writ to the Indiana Supreme court denied. WHY? we now have taken one of these to the U.S. Supreme Court, and are presenttly waiting to see if they will hear our case. Thanks, MJS> A concerned grandparent

Michael Jack Stephens,     Dated:  18.05.08   Time:  23:01 Web:
Country:  usa  City: Bloomingdale  State: georgia
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Olga Stickel  Court: Elkhart Superior Court 4, Elkhart, Indiana
Judge Olga Stickel, and the Elkhart County Prosecutor did nothing to help us, when the first Judges recused himself for the criminal case for Child Support guidline violations. They prosecuted this defendant in direct violation of what the Indiana Code states: \"Support\" means \'food,clothing,shelter,and medical care\'. This defendant was prosecuted for non payment of a court order under false pretense of non support of a defendant child, which in Indiana law is two completely different Statutes. If support means the above, then why is the mothers not so charged also, when they are the custodial parent. The mother is the one responsible for the food clothing shelter and medical care, not the non custodial parent. NO WHERE DOES THE CRIMINAL STATUTE STATE THAT THE PAYMENT OF MONEY IS WITHIN THE MEANING OF SUPPORT. Yet non custodial parents are being falsely prosecuted in Indiana in direct violation of what the Indiana Code states. This judge did nothing to help, just sent a young man to jail. How can anyone pay child support sitting in jail? I have never understood this. This judge should be removed from office by a Bill of Impeachment to the Indiana House of Representatives. This judge violated her Oath of Office, does not have a bond on file either, and violated the Indiana code as too child support. THERE IS NO JUSTICE IN INDIANA FOR ANYONE, WAKE UP AMERIC



Anonymous,     Dated:  18.06.08   Time:  11:45 Web: Country:  USA  City: Charleston  State: SC Rating: Evil"  Judge: Francis P Segars-Andrews  Court: District 10 Judge demonstrates arrogant atittude, incompetentcy, bias behaviors,county of origin descrimination,engages and conspires with selective attorneys for favorable decisions. arbitrarily sets attorneys fees favorable to litigants and attorneys without evidence for such fees. This judge should be removed from the bench pronto!!
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Francis P Segars-Andrews  Court: District 10
Judge demonstrates arrogant atittude, incompetentcy, bias behaviors,county of origin descrimination,engages and conspires with selective attorneys for favorable decisions. arbitrarily sets attorneys fees favorable to litigants and attorneys without evidence for such fees. This judge should be removed from the bench pronto!!

Anonymous,     Dated:  18.06.08   Time:  11:45 Web:
Country:  USA  City: Charleston  State: SC
Rating: Evil"  Judge: Francis P Segars-Andrews  Court: District 10
Judge demonstrates arrogant atittude, incompetentcy, bias behaviors,county of origin descrimination,engages and conspires with selective attorneys for favorable decisions. arbitrarily sets attorneys fees favorable to litigants and attorneys without evidence for such fees. This judge should be removed from the bench pronto!!





































Number of User Comments: 55    View, maybe join, HaigReport/Corrupt Judges Mailing list

   Your GENUINE COMMENTS will add towards CURBING JUDICIAL IMMUNITY of judges, WORLDWIDE. That this is possible, is a major positive impact of the Internet. We do not need a change of the law to make Judges accountable. You comments, together with comments of other "plain citizens" throughout the world, who would be the people to comprise an Independant GRAND JURY, will cause this to occur.     See how this will occur on our Parent website - * Each field must have content before it can be saved
 
Proceed to the NEW IMPROVED forum for Rating Judges of
US of A [United States of America] plus much more]
. See our NEW EXTENDED POLICY:
 
    Enter Your Name *

    Enter your Country  *  City *   State *

    Judges Full Name:  *   Judges Court/Jurisdiction *    Rating *

    
  Type your assessment of this Judge with reference to a particular decision or conduct of Judge *
  Web Site: http:// Optional